Payless Pizza

Discover Payless Pizza in Portland, IN – enjoy delicious breadsticks, flavorful potatoes, and friendly service at our cozy pizza restaurant. Call +1 260-726-9722 for your next meal!

Welcome to Payless Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Payless Pizza
Payless Pizza
Payless Pizza
Payless Pizza

Located in the heart of Portland, Indiana, Payless Pizza offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike. A perfect spot for a casual meal with friends or a family gathering, this eatery shines with its friendly staff and a menu that caters to a variety of tastes. Whether you're craving pizza, sandwiches, or even a hearty salad, Payless Pizza has something for everyone. Sitting right at 117 1/2 E North St, this charming establishment emanates the spirit of community dining, making it a favorite among locals. With a phone number at +1 260-726-9722, questions or takeout orders are just a call away, ensuring that your delicious meal is both convenient and accessible.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

117 1/2 E North St, Portland, IN 47371, United States

Phone

+1 260-726-9722

About

The Culinary Story

Payless Pizza
Payless Pizza
Payless Pizza
Payless Pizza

Payless Pizza has carved a niche for itself in Portland’s vibrant dining scene. It is not just a restaurant; it is a community landmark where friendship and food intersect. Since opening its doors, Payless has attracted families, friends, and even visitors looking for that perfect slice of pizza. The eatery’s menu is thoughtfully curated, featuring not only pizzas but also a variety of sandwiches, salads, and mouthwatering Mexican dishes. Each dish reflects the commitment to quality and taste that the restaurant is known for.

When entering Payless Pizza, customers are often greeted with smiles from the friendly staff, who treat diners like family. This personal touch enhances the overall dining experience and keeps patrons coming back for more. From the moment you step inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizzas fills the air, creating an almost nostalgic feeling as familiar favorites dance in the mind. Payless Pizza understands the importance of comfort food, and every dish is a testament to that belief.

Payless Pizza’s commitment to quality translates into its sourcing of local ingredients whenever possible. The cooks whip up everything from hearty breaded tenderloins to classic beef nachos with passion and attention to detail. Not only does the menu cater to everyone’s craving, but there’s also an ongoing effort to provide delicious options for all taste preferences. Veggie lovers can enjoy enticing salads while meat lovers can indulge in robust sandwiches and pizzas loaded with toppings. This dedication to diverse choices ensures that every visit yields something fresh and satisfying.

Moreover, patrons can rely on the restaurant to uphold community values, frequently engaging in events that bless the area with food donations and sponsorships. It transforms dining out into a communal experience, reinforcing connections among locals. Payless Pizza doesn’t just serve food—it serves togetherness, making each meal more meaningful.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday4-8:30 PM
  • Thursday4-8:30 PM
  • Friday4-9:30 PM
  • Saturday4-9 PM

The team at Payless Pizza takes pride in its diverse menu, featuring a robust selection of 42 dishes spanning multiple categories. Begin your meal with warm, cheesy breadsticks that set the tone for a satisfying culinary journey. Their sandwich section is a highlight, showcasing options from a classic Hamburger to the unique Slaw Burger, each made with fresh ingredients and crafted to perfection. Those looking for something refreshing can explore the salad options, including the hearty Paradise Deluxe or the ever-popular Fried Chicken Club.

The Mexican dishes steal the spotlight as well, with the Beef Nacho Supreme earning rave reviews. Payless Pizza also offers a variety of drink options and sides that complement any meal, making it a versatile dining destination for all occasions.

Payless Pizza

The exterior of Payless Pizza reflects its inviting nature, with a simple yet welcoming facade that speaks to both the casual diner and the gourmet. Situated conveniently on E North St, the restaurant blends seamlessly into the charming streets of Portland. Bright signage draws the eye, while large windows give a glimpse into the bustling activity within. The outdoor seating options, when available, provide a relaxing experience for those who enjoy dining al fresco while taking in the local vibe.

The overall ambiance feels like home, encouraging long conversations over great meals.

Patrons often leave behind their worries at the door, immersing themselves in a cozy environment that feels both familiar and cherished.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Always delicious food. People are very nice and I eat there quite often. You get alot for your money and its not expensive. I'd recommend this to anyone wanting anything from a baked steak dinner to pizza.

J
Jodee B.

Place was awesome we were helped by some lovely lady named Katie, she was so professional and was always right there when we needed her and we will back because of her and will recommend this place because of her.

D
Dustin H.

I've never gotten anything I didn't like! Chicken stir fry potato is amazing...salads are fantastic! Chicken pizza best ever!

D
Debra V.

Always great atmosphere and I love the kind caring workers and love Carla and Doyle great business people who love to have you smile and enjoy the food you ordered and hot when you get it delivered thanks love you guys

K
Kenneth P.

It's good pizza love the bread sticks.just a friendly bussies. The owner is so nices.prices are good also go check them out if you haven't already.

K
Kim M.

THE BEST breadsticks around. Delicious pizza. The staff is so friendly and welcoming. Been going here since I was a little girl.

S
Shelby A.